February 12, 2017

Loved It: A Study in Scarlet by Sherry Thomas

Series: Lady Sherlock 1
Format: Paperback
Release Date: October 18, 2016
Publisher: Berkley
Source: Publisher
Genre: Historical Mystery

USA Today bestselling author Sherry Thomas turns the story of the renowned Sherlock Holmes upside down…

With her inquisitive mind, Charlotte Holmes has never felt comfortable with the demureness expected of the fairer sex in upper class society. But even she never thought that she would become a social pariah, an outcast fending for herself on the mean streets of London.

When the city is struck by a trio of unexpected deaths and suspicion falls on her sister and her father, Charlotte is desperate to find the true culprits and clear the family name. She’ll have help from friends new and old—a kind-hearted widow, a police inspector, and a man who has long loved her. But in the end, it will be up to Charlotte, under the assumed name Sherlock Holmes, to challenge society’s expectations and match wits against an unseen mastermind.

I'm sure a lot of you have either heard or have had the pleasure of reading Sherry Thomas' A STUDY IN SCARLET, the debut novel in her new historical mystery series, Lady Sherlock. I'm sure you've also seen rave reviews for it, endless praises, and a variety of critiques. Allow me to add my bit to the pile, I promise I'll make it short and sweet.

Like the majority, I had fun reading A STUDY IN SCARLET. It's very feminist, to say the least as SThomas clearly empowered her female-dominated cast while maintaining strict decorum in order to preserve the eras (sad) gender inequality issues. The whole ploy behind Charlotte Holmes' and Mrs. Watson assuming male roles are both clever and simplified. Some might argue that it's too simple, but considering how big men's egos were at that time and how little they think of women, the oversight is plausible.

True to form, A STUDY IN SCARLET's mystery aspect with the brilliant Charlotte Holmes at its helm I every bit "Sherlock" from her impressive deductive reasoning skills, matter of fact observations, and sometimes off the wall comments. The only big difference to me is that Charlotte and Mrs. Watson do not have direct contact with crime solving and there's not much action here either, all of which I hope will change in the succeeding books.

Overall, I think Sir Conan Doyle would approve of SThomas' attempt at reimagining Sherlock. It's cleverly plotted, character driven, and is successful in mashing-up a historical classic with contemporary flavor to appeal to readers of our time. I look forward to the next one mostly to see the infamous Moriarty's incarnation in this world.

Talk Supe


  1. Oh yes I did read this one but if I remember well I think was bothering me in this one.... I'll take a look

  2. Yep, I was definitely one of the fans. I can't wait for book two. I'm so curious about Moriarity, but want all the rest of the cast, too.

  3. I've long since given up on this era. I can't handle the blatant sexism which was true in the period. :/

  4. That is certainly different. Not my type of book but interesting.

  5. This isn't really a genre I read so I haven't heard of this before but it sounds like you really enjoyed it.

  6. I totally want to read this. I've heard that both her romance and YA books are really good. Love the cover!

  7. I've been eyeing this one for a while, so I'm glad to hear its a good read. Great review!

  8. I have this one -so I'm even MORE excited to read it now!!


  9. Oh wow I want this. I'm not usually a historical fiction fan (unless its WWII) but this sounds Fabulous. Great review!

  10. Glad you enjoyed this, it has been one on my wishlist.

  11. Sounds like a fun read... good mystery and plot!

  12. Gah! I have to, have to read this one!! It sounds so well done and I love the Holmes twist. Hopefully my library has it!

  13. I need this!!! Oh wow it sounds like such a good read! I'm going to show it to my sister. She's going to get so mad because she's used up her book allowance lol. I'm a bad influence on her.

  14. ooh glad this one was a winner. I have been wanting to try it out. I like that it stayed true to the era and still had some "feminism" aspects too. I love it when authors write these type of books, because it shows the strength women had in these era's despite the opposition to their rights.

  15. Yes I've heard of this one before, on Anna from Herding Cats and Burning Soup if I remember correctly. While I like mysteries and especially cozy mysteries, I haven't read a lot of historical mysteries yet, although I would like to give them a try. This sounds like a good one!

  16. Yas!!! I loved this one. I'm so glad to see you had a great time with it, too! I'm really curious what will happen next :D


My reviews are subjective & does not reflect that of Talk Supe's followers.

Also I LOVE commenting back so if you're checking out a post, leave a line or two and I promise to visit your blog back. Let's feed each other's blogger soul!